Originally posted by gteeitup:
you think top 10 programs have years when they don't make the dance or lose before the sweet 16?...
You mean like how UK (a team you rated as a top 10 program) missed the tournament 3 years ago? Or do you mean like how duke (another team you rated as a top 10 program) has lost in the first round 2 out of the last 3 years?
Hmmm, funny because before this latest 3 year run of being in the NCAA tournament, Wichita St had missed 5 consecutive NCAA tournaments before that.
Oh, and what do you know?...VCU has lost before the sweet 16 in the last 3 NCAA tournaments.
And what about those mighty Arizona Wildcats? Well, they haven't made a Final Four since winning it all in 1997. And they missed the dance in 2010 and 2012 (where they lost in the first round of the NIT).
What about Wisconsin, you ask?...in 2009, 2010 and 2013, they failed to make the sweet 16.
But the defending champion UConn Huskies must have better recent success in the tournament than us, right? Well,...they've missed 3 NCAA tournaments since 2007 and lost in the first round in 2 other years since 2007. But yeah, they won the championship last year so that must mean they're a better program than us.
Well Louisville certainly hasn't missed the tournament since Pitino got there...what?...they have? Yep, they missed the tournament in 2005-2006 and they failed to make the sweet 16 in 3 other years since Pitino has been there.
Originally posted by gteeitup:
the debate is carolina being a top 10 program right now...right now, imo, carolina is not a top 10 basketball program.
You keep saying this but all you are offering up is some subjective criteria which I just shredded. If you want to say that UNC is not a top 10 team this year, then fine. If you want to say that UNC hasn't met your personal expectations, that too is fine. But you attempted to list 10 programs that you think are better programs than UNC and I just shot holes all in it. I think it's clear that at least 5 of the programs you listed are not better programs.
Originally posted by gteeitup:
and of course greg marshall isn't going to compare programs...that's our job and right now, witchita st. looks better.
Greg Marshall wouldn't say it. Bilas wouldn't say it. Coach K wouldn't say it. Pitino, Izzo, Boeheim, Bob Knight, Bill Raftery, Greg Anderson, Vitale and many, many more wouldn't say it. In fact, the only people that would say it would be UNC fans that are being a bit reactionary and overdramatic about our recent play.
This post was edited on 12/31 9:43 AM by gunslingerdick