ADVERTISEMENT

Rank 'em Best N.C. BBQ

prlyles

Hall of Famer
Aug 19, 2006
17,053
3,588
113
The following are the best I've had in the state. I only list places that still cook with wood. Feel free to add or take away.

Skylight Inn Adyen
Bum's Ayden
Stamey's Greensboro
Lexington #1 Lexington
Smiley's Lexington
 
Originally posted by JuleZ '02 HEEL:
Out of those I'm ashamed to admit I have only been to Skylight. And it is worthy of its reputation.

B's cooks over charcoal and always has, but nevertheless is one of the best.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
I've wanted to try B's for a long time but I can never catch them open when I'm down east.
 
There is no great bbq in wilmington. One of the few things i dislike living here. Theres a couple decent places but both serve canned beans and sauce and bagged slaw. If someone came here with a genuine smokehouse bbq they would kill it.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
 
Hursey's in Burlington still cooks with wood.

Stamey's is ok.

Monk's (Lex#1) is the uncontested king.
 
I left off one of the best in the state!! (old age I guess)

Wilber's in Goldsboro
 
Originally posted by prlyles:
I left off one of the best in the state!! (old age I guess)

Wilber's in Goldsboro
Wilber's is the best eastern Carolina bbq that I've enjoyed . . . Parker's in Wilson is almost as good, and the hush puppies at Parker's may be the best tasting I've had . .

Haven't been to Skylight Inn or anything in Lexington.
 
Originally posted by BillyL:

Originally posted by prlyles:
I left off one of the best in the state!! (old age I guess)

Wilber's in Goldsboro
Wilber's is the best eastern Carolina bbq that I've enjoyed . . . Parker's in Wilson is almost as good, and the hush puppies at Parker's may be the best tasting I've had . .

Haven't been to Skylight Inn or anything in Lexington.
It would be hard for me to pick between Wilber's and Skylight. If I was eating just BBQ I would give Skylight a slight edge but Wilber's have better side dishes. The best combination of BBQ and sides would be Bum's IMO.
 
I do love Wilber's boiled potatoes, green beans, collard greens and cole slaw . . another thing that I appreciate from Wilber's that Parker's doesn't offer, is the Carolina BBQ chicken. Parker's has chicken with a red based sauce.

I usually only get to eat there twice a year, coming and going from the southern NC beaches . . but, on the way to the beach, we load up with plenty of food to take with us.

I'm getting hungry now
party0021.r191677.gif
. .
 
Billy called me an ol' Virginia boy that wouldn't know anything about NC BBQ spots. That's sort of accurate. I'm actually a NC boy by birth but was raised mostly Virginian. To that end, I don't know many of the places on the OP's list. But I certainly know a thing or two about good 'cue. I give all the credit in the world to NC for being the BBQ capital of the world. But don't sleep on VA. We got pigs and pits too. I'd be happy to show some BBQ eaters around the Central VA area if y'all ever made it up this way.

But for NC BBQ spots, I'd like to submit Short Sugar's in Reidsville.
 
Long time lurker but had to chime in on this one. I lived in Wayne county for over 40 years. Have eaten at Wilbers, Parkers and many others. The best by far is a little place at Coker's Mill, just outside Goldsboro called Stonewalls!
 
Originally posted by nctransplant:

Long time lurker but had to chime in on this one. I lived in Wayne county for over 40 years. Have eaten at Wilbers, Parkers and many others. The best by far is a little place at Coker's Mill, just outside Goldsboro called Stonewalls!
I've heard some very good things about Stonewalls on other boards, I'm going to have to give them a try . . and btw, welcome to the board, nctransplant . .
 
Originally posted by nctransplant:

Long time lurker but had to chime in on this one. I lived in Wayne county for over 40 years. Have eaten at Wilbers, Parkers and many others. The best by far is a little place at Coker's Mill, just outside Goldsboro called Stonewalls!
Is that the place that has BBQ turkey also?
 
He has BBQ turkey on Wednesdays. It is ridiculous as well. BBQ and BBQ chicken on Saturday's. In fact, everyday he has something good.

Thanks Billy.
 
What about Alston Bridges BBQ in Shelby? Haven't been there in a few years but was pretty dang good!
 
Of the ones listed all I've been to is Smileys and Lexingon BBQ.

I'll take Smileys all day long!
 
I hate to admit that I have not eaten at any of the OP's original list. I've always wanted to get to Skylight and Bum's but don't go through Ayden very often. B's BBQ is outstanding, however, and their chicken is GREAT. Parker's, Bill's, McCall's, Wilbur's-I really don't have a preference. I like them all. I don't know that much about western NC BBQ, so I will not start any arguments there, but I have tried the stuff from SC and was not impressed.
 
Originally posted by jbradsh1:
What about Alston Bridges BBQ in Shelby? Haven't been there in a few years but was pretty dang good!
Bridges BBQ is on my list of ones I want to eat at. It's very highly rated by those who know N.C. BBQ.
 
I've only eaten at Stameys on this list. Always loved it b/c my Uncle Joe always had their BBQ in the fridge/freezer when we would visit from Charlotte. If you are in Myrtle Beach, I highly recommend Simply Southern. Great BBQ & chicken bog on the buffet!!
 
I live in Benson...I'd walk to Wilber's before I'd eat at Parker's.

White Swan in Smithfield is OK. Their franchises elsewhere suck, IMO.

King's in Kinston.

Moore's in New Bern

Smithfield Chicken & BBQ isn't bad...for shoulders cooked in electric ovens.
 
Originally posted by prlyles:
The following are the best I've had in the state. I only list places that still cook with wood. Feel free to add or take away.

Skylight Inn Adyen
Bum's Ayden
Stamey's Greensboro
Lexington #1 Lexington
Smiley's Lexington
This is like trying to say which child is your favorite.
 
Originally posted by T-Square:
Originally posted by prlyles:
The following are the best I've had in the state. I only list places that still cook with wood. Feel free to add or take away.

Skylight Inn Adyen
Bum's Ayden
Stamey's Greensboro
Lexington #1 Lexington
Smiley's Lexington
This is like trying to say which child is your favorite.
You have a point...lol
 
Originally posted by heelbent:

I live in Benson...I'd walk to Wilber's before I'd eat at Parker's.

White Swan in Smithfield is OK. Their franchises elsewhere suck, IMO.

King's in Kinston.

Moore's in New Bern

Smithfield Chicken & BBQ isn't bad...for shoulders cooked in electric ovens.
Yeah, I've heard Parker's has really went downhill since they quit cooking with wood.
 
There was another place just outside of Goldsboro that had really good BBQ as well, Grady's. I believe he has since closed. They had great BBQ as well.
 
Originally posted by heelbent:

I live in Benson...I'd walk to Wilber's before I'd eat at Parker's.

White Swan in Smithfield is OK. Their franchises elsewhere suck, IMO.

King's in Kinston.

Moore's in New Bern

Smithfield Chicken & BBQ isn't bad...for shoulders cooked in electric ovens.
I do like Smithfields, they got a new place in Greensboro, it's pretty dern good eatin!
 
Originally posted by mikeirbyusa:

I do like Smithfields, they got a new place in Greensboro, it's pretty dern good eatin!
The guy that started Smithfield's is part of the Moore family that owns the BBQ place in New Bern. I met him when I was at Lejeune and he was running the store in Jax. Nice guy, real friendly. I told him I had worked at Bedsole's Pig-n-Chicken in Hope Mills when I was a kid. He told me to come see him about a job when I got out.

I saw him again on WRAL years later when he was being sued by an employee for sexual harrassment...a male employee. Prior Marine, IIRC. The employee won.

I imagine Julie Moore owns the store in Greensboro. She won, too. ;)
 
Originally posted by mikeirbyusa:
Originally posted by heelbent:

I live in Benson...I'd walk to Wilber's before I'd eat at Parker's.

White Swan in Smithfield is OK. Their franchises elsewhere suck, IMO.

King's in Kinston.

Moore's in New Bern

Smithfield Chicken & BBQ isn't bad...for shoulders cooked in electric ovens.
I do like Smithfields, they got a new place in Greensboro, it's pretty dern good eatin!
I think Smithfields BBQ is as good as fast food BBQ can be but it's still nothing close to the real thing IMO.
 
My favorite BBQ joint is whichever one my posterior is currently sitting in. I love em all, and can usually find something good about each one.

That said, it's hard to beat Lexington #1. The hush puppies, the slaw, the outside brown cuts, the dip and the hot BBQ sauce. Dayum, I need to get on the road and head up there!
 
Originally posted by prlyles:

I think Smithfields BBQ is as good as fast food BBQ can be but it's still nothing close to the real thing IMO.
They sure charge like a premium joint. More expensive than Wilber's by about 20%.
 
Originally posted by nctransplant:

There was another place just outside of Goldsboro that had really good BBQ as well, Grady's. I believe he has since closed. They had great BBQ as well.
Grady's is still open.

Supposedly a really good place between Princeton and Rosewood on Hwy 70.
 
Must be a different Grady's then. Then one I am talking about is near Sleepy Creek.
This post was edited on 1/28 4:06 PM by nctransplant
 
Originally posted by nctransplant:

Must be a different Grady's then. Then one I am talking about is near Sleepy Creek.


This post was edited on 1/28 4:06 PM by nctransplant
That is Grady's. They are still in business.

I don't know the name of the place between Princeton and Rosewood. (Not Grady's)
This post was edited on 1/28 4:30 PM by eec212020
 
Originally posted by eec212020:
Originally posted by nctransplant:

Must be a different Grady's then. Then one I am talking about is near Sleepy Creek.


This post was edited on 1/28 4:06 PM by nctransplant
That is Grady's. They are still in business.

I don't know the name of the place between Princeton and Rosewood. (Not Grady's)
This post was edited on 1/28 4:30 PM by eec212020
I think the place you're referring to is Adam's Roadside BBQ. I've never tried it.
 
Originally posted by heelmanwilm:
There is no great bbq in wilmington. One of the few things i dislike living here. Theres a couple decent places but both serve canned beans and sauce and bagged slaw. If someone came here with a genuine smokehouse bbq they would kill it.
Posted from Rivals Mobile
I'd go to Smithfield's.
 
I cannot believe no one has mentioned B's BBQ in Greenville, NC. I have eaten at every BBQ joint listed in this thread and B's is by far the best.
 
any good places off 95 north or 64 east on my way to the obx?

we used to go to this place in williamston near the holiday inn but i can't recall the name.
 
Originally posted by Louigi:
I cannot believe no one has mentioned B's BBQ in Greenville, NC. I have eaten at every BBQ joint listed in this thread and B's is by far the best.
B's was mentioned in one of the first post. I've tried to eat there twice but both times they were closed. I understand they just cook so much BBQ a day and when that runs out they close but you're right, they are ranked right up there with the best in the state. Hope to try it sometime.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT