ADVERTISEMENT

Coaching 'fit' is a real and important thing

WoadBlue

Hall of Famer
Aug 15, 2008
20,317
4,269
113
In fact, it always has been the best reason for UNC to rehire Mack Brown: he is an easy 'fit' in Chapel Hill and at UNC. Yes, that can be used as a silly excuse to make and keep bad hires (such as Bunting), but it nonetheless always should be taken into account at every turn.

Auburn boosters by and large are nuts and vicious, and they gravely harmed the program they love by undermining Harsin before he ever held a practice as Tiger HC. That said, it also is true that Harsin, who was 50 games over .500 at Boise St with 5 double digit win seasons out of 6 possible such seasons, is a westerner who is not close to a natural fit to any SEC program.

I think the best way to understand 'fit' right now is Bret Bielema. As a young, 1st time HC, he won 3 BT championships at Wisconsin. He also had a 12-1 team that did not win the BT. And he was an IL country boy, actually raised on a hog farm. So it seemed logical to assume that he could win at Arkansas. But his 5 year record there was 29-34. Bielema never could fit into Arkansas or the SEC. He was a midwestern fish out of water around Fayetteville and among HS coaches ands recruits across the southwest and the SEC area. He stood out as an odd duck among SEC coaches at SEC Media Days.

And now look at Bielema. In 2021 he took over the basket case that is Illini football. Before Bielema, Lovie Smith had 5 consecutive losing teams at Illinois and was 22 games under .500. In his first year in Champaign-Urbana, Bielema was 5-7, and this year, the long inept Illini are 7-1 and ranked #14. Midwestern born and raised, and BT trained (he played at Iowa and was an assistant at Iowa and was Wisconsin DC before being named Wisconsin HC), Bielema is a fit in the BT. He is working a small miracle now in the BT.
 
i agree. mack is a good fit for carolina, the primary reason being he genuinely loves it here and not just a job.
Sally loves it more. She was a Chapel Hill resident, and very happy and successful, before Mack arrived. Back in '97, I thought that Baddour basically did nothing to keep Mack until it was too late because he thought that Sally would not allow him to leave Chapel Hill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: randman1
I'm interested to see how Brian Kelly pans out at LSU. That, to me, isn't a good fit. But he does have quite a bit of talent to work with.
It doesn't seem to be, but neither did Nick Sabin. A difference between LSU and other SEC teams in terms of coaches like Saban and Kelly is the large number of Catholics in Louisiana. They find a very large and natural set of fans and major boosters willing to give them a fairly long honeymoon that they could not have at Auburn.

Of course, if they fail to deliver, even after winning big, they are going to be sent packing, as favorite son Oregon proves.

Kelly should have very good or great talent at LSU every year. If he keeps winning, he'll fit in easily enough. In fact, the 'channel Irish' in New Orleans have an accent that sounds more like that of Brooklyn than the small town New England crossed with small town midwestern one that Kelly has.
 
It doesn't seem to be, but neither did Nick Sabin. A difference between LSU and other SEC teams in terms of coaches like Saban and Kelly is the large number of Catholics in Louisiana. They find a very large and natural set of fans and major boosters willing to give them a fairly long honeymoon that they could not have at Auburn.

Of course, if they fail to deliver, even after winning big, they are going to be sent packing, as favorite son Oregon proves.

Kelly should have very good or great talent at LSU every year. If he keeps winning, he'll fit in easily enough. In fact, the 'channel Irish' in New Orleans have an accent that sounds more like that of Brooklyn than the small town New England crossed with small town midwestern one that Kelly has.
Good point. Had totally forgotten about their history and Catholic population.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT