Mt Rushmore of...

[dadika13]

the two catches made those drives...and if you’re being honest, you know that.

I'll give you the Tyree catch, but, Eli did a HELL of a job avoiding the sack on that play to extend it.

And the Manningham catch was an absolute dime pass by Eli.

Sorry dude, you're not going to get me to downplay Eli's role in those two Super Bowls. I'll obviously agree he was mediocre in the regular season in his career, but he was money in the two biggest games of his life.

 

[Raising Heel]

If you don't think Shaq had skill and finesse then we weren't watching the same player from 1997-2003. Highlights were dunks sure, but Shaq had so many moves and his footwork was unbelievable. I put him right up there in skillset with the greats.

I never said he didn't have skill and finesse. The problem IMO is that they weren't on display often enough because it was much easier for him to bull his way to the rim. Not entirely his fault, however, because the NBA didn't know what to do about a continent with arms and legs and so he never got whistled for wrecking defenders who had established position.

 

[Raising Heel]

my Eli

You are hereby disqualified from further discussions of Eli Manning.

ETA: I see now that you've changed it, but Freudian slips happen to the best of us.

 

[dadika13]

You are hereby disqualified from further discussions of Eli Manning.

ETA: I see now that you've changed it, but Freudian slips happen to the best of us.

Hahaha, definite typo but also possible Freudian.

 

[toophly1124]

I'll give you the Tyree catch, but, Eli did a HELL of a job avoiding the sack on that play to extend it.

And the Manningham catch was an absolute dime pass by Eli.

Sorry dude, you're not going to get me to downplay Eli's role in those two Super Bowls. I'll obviously agree he was mediocre in the regular season in his career, but he was money in the two biggest games of his life.

Facts.

 

[Hark_The_Sound_2010]

Sorry dude, you're not going to get me to downplay Eli's role in those two Super Bowls. I'll obviously agree he was mediocre in the regular season in his career, but he was money in the two biggest games of his life.

And that's how you get into the overrated conversation. People remember him and cite those two games as to why he's a good/great QB. He may have played well in those two games, but calling him mediocre for the rest of his regular season career is probably even a bit generous.

It's interesting that he's so opposite of his brother. Peyton had unbelievable regular season numbers, and then in the post season had a steady stream of poo rolling down his leg.

 

[toophly1124]

And that's how you get into the overrated conversation. People remember him and cite those two games as to why he's a good/great QB. He may have played well in those two games, but calling him mediocre for the rest of his regular season career is probably even a bit generous.

It's interesting that he's so opposite of his brother. Peyton had unbelievable regular season numbers, and then in the post season had a steady stream of poo rolling down his leg.

You’re just sour he kicked Brady’s ass twice. Tell it like it is Joey.

 

[Hark_The_Sound_2010]

You’re just sour he kicked Brady’s ass twice. Tell it like it is Joey.

Beyond sour.

 

[Raising Heel]

It's interesting that he's so opposite of his brother. Peyton had unbelievable regular season numbers, and then in the post season had a steady stream of poo rolling down his leg.

Good point. Now I'm going to watch every regular season Giants game and have to check Eli's leg.

 

[BillyL]

You’re just sour he kicked Brady’s ass twice. Tell it like it is Joey.

Uh-oh . . . the 'Joey' designation just appeared . . sh!t be getting serious now.

 

[toophly1124]

Uh-oh . . . the 'Joey' designation just appeared . . sh!t be getting serious now.

Lol be careful or I’ll call your name too

 

[BillyL]

Lol be careful or I’ll call your name too

It's who I am . . . and how I roll.

 

[toophly1124]

It's who I am . . . and how I roll.

Young Guns fantastic movie