Okay just now having time to respond to this thread
@coolwaterunc @carolinablue34
There's no reason to have Brandon McCarthy in this rotation anymore. The dude is an automatic L.
Newcomb
Folty
Soroka
Teheran
Sanchez
That should be it until further notice.
I agree that I really do not want McCarthy in the starting rotation anymore. The problem is our pitching health is on very shaky ground. Said another way, one of our regular starters keeps getting injured and thus the need for McCarthy continues. First Soroka had the shoulder issues (does air quotes), now Folty will probably miss a start or two. And Newcomb requires an extra day's rest, per the front office, so we are still making that happen. And, of course, Teheran has his issues.
So there keeps being a need for a guy, and Snitker / the FO decide that McCarthy is that guy. My only hope is that we are putting him in the display window for someone with pitching issues to go after him (cough, Dodgers). I do not want McCarthy to go the pen... he would be useless except as a long-relief man when we are already winning or losing by 7 runs. I would prefer it be Fried. He has looked decent when given the opportunity, and it would kill two birds with one stone because it would also give other MLB clubs more chances to see him pitch so we can trade him.
That brings us to the bullpen. The bullpen is 1 part awesome and 1 equal part house of cards. Winkler is a beast 99% of the time. Minter is a beast 80% of the time (my God, last night he was effing filthy. If he's that "on" he's unhittable.). Vizzy is horrifying and scary and heart attack-inducing, but still, 80% of the time, he ultimately gets the job done. Carle is effective ~65% of the time. Sam Freeman.... he's not getting it done. From what I read from people who know baseball better than me, he
could be effective still, but he needs to be managed the right way........... i.e., stop letting him face righties lol. Other than that, though, our bullpen is awfulllllllllllllll. Awful. We need help there bad.