Y'all are in luck. I have arrived to set the record straight on several things discussed in this thread.
1 - OBWAT is not overrated or underrated. It's rated right where it should be rated. It's a fantastic movie.
2 - Lebowski, Raising Arizona, Fargo and OBWAT are the best Coen movies and you can put them in any order you like.
3 - Burn After Reading was good but not in the same league as the other Coen movies being discussed. If I need a 5th for my top 5 Coen movies, I'll take Intolerable Cruelty. If for no other reason than Catherine Zeta Jones looks hotter in that movie than any woman has ever looked in any other movie.
4 - LOTR is strictly for kids under the age of 15 and geeks.
5 - Office Space is slightly overrated. It's a funny movie. But it's not as good as some folks make it out to be. It's not a top 10 comedy for me yet some people act like it's the funniest movie ever. It's a classic "cult following" film. Those who love it, really, really love it.
There. That's all settled now.