Originally posted by gunslingerdick:
Originally posted by GoNtheDistance:
this is probably one of the better threads we've had all year. I think JP is an elite jumper. His bounce is crazy good, we all know that. like one poster mentioned though, due to his gate or whatever you want to call it, he is very limited with flexibility in his movement which makes him look clumsy/lazy, etc.
the most glaring points are that JP is simply not a good shooter. His mechanics aren't the kind that I think you can fix over the course of a summer and expect significant improvement. His only shot should be a layup, dunk or free throw. I stand by that. I also challenge the idea that he's an elite defender. He's simply no in my opinion, stats support that. He got blown up a lot this season against players that frankly, I thought he had the length to bother or at least challenge much more than he did. He routinely misses assignments and loses his man in the half court sets. On more than a few occasions, I witnessed Brice or Fat Fat pick up a stupid foul trying to fend off an interior shot from an offensive player that Tokoto lost sight of. and I don't mean to downplay the importance that Tokoto has on our team because I think he has a fit as a specialist for us that can come off the bench and provide energy and effort, but the assist numbers for him are greatly skewed. Frankly, outside of Marcus, he was the only player to control the basketball for us significantly. Britt and Berry almost cancelled each other out throughout the year in minutes which left us with JP trying to dribble around until Marcus could get a glimpse of an opening for a good shot when we needed it. This resulted in just as many terrible games as good games with JP handling the basketball. For every good pass he made, I'd argue that he made a pass equally as bad for a turnover. In saying that, he's not a PG and I fault Roy pretty heavily for not giving Berry more minutes earlier in the season to develop a viable ball handler who can get to the rim and free up more open shots than anybody else on our roster. JP did the best he could given his skill set and I applaud him for stepping up to accept a role in which he truly wasn't equipped for. If you look at the tail end of the year, JP, Marcus, Justin and even Britt in some games, greatly benefitted from Berry's ability to spread the floor and beat people off the dribble. This opened up passing lanes for open 3's, and also opened up cutting lanes for a player like JP to get into the paint for a shot.
I applaud JP for all he does for our team, but I truly believe that until we add another scorer on the perimeter to take JP's spot, we are looking at another team that carries close to double digit losses into postseason. We just aren't efficient offensively with JP on the floor. His inability to shoot or create off the dribble allow teams to essentially play a man free to clog up the paint, get in passing lanes, double the post, etc.
I disagree with much of this. First and foremost is the idea that JP would be a 6th man. How many players in the 6th man role are poor offensive players? The whole idea of a 6th man is that you're bringing instant offense off the bench. It would be weird to bring a defender/slasher/passer off the bench in a 6th man role. That's just weird to me.
JP is a legit defender. Yes, he got eaten up sometimes. But so did every player on our team. At least JP was eaten up by the other team's best player. Some of our guys failed against marginal players on opposing teams. JP was given the toughest assignment pretty much every game. And more times than not, he succeeded. You mention "numbers" proving that he's a poor defender. I'd like to see those numbers. What numbers would you be referencing?
His shooting is not great. But it's not terrible. His biggest problem IMO is knowing when to shoot. When he's open at the top of the key, he needs to shoot it. An open 3 is a better shot than a contested 15' fadeaway. I think that can be coached. I also have hope for him to become a better shooter. His FT percentage improved from Soph to Junior years. Why couldn't his jumpshot?
Regarding his stride and how he gets up and down the court, I'm not going to lie...there's something weird about it. It looks like he too often jumps off the wrong foot or that his legs aren't underneath him when he jumps. It's odd for sure. Not sure this is a correctable issue. Some of y'all are bemoaning his ball-handling but where would we be without it? Y'all are underselling his abilities. His turnovers throughout the year came on ill-advised passes; not on ball-handling mistakes. I do agree that many of his turnovers were a result on the coaching he's gotten in that he sometimes seemed like he didn't know what to do with the ball. Some of y'all are attributing this to him just dribbling around aimlessly. But I put that on Roy not instructing him properly.
But the bottom line for me is that JP offers far more in the plus than he does in the minus. I don't know his rebounding numbers on the season, but I'd like someone to do some serious number crunching and tell me when most of those rebounds came. To me, JP seemed to have knack for getting big rebounds - at important times in the games. And the way he gets some of those rebounds are almost like dunks - in that they are demoralizing for the opponent. They're momentum changers. His hands are super active and his steals are often momentum changers as well.
I kind of like the idea of going small as another poster suggested with JP at the 4. Because I am now a believer in Berry. I believe that Berry has to be a starter next year. But I just can't see taking JP off the floor. To me he brings too much. His ball handling is needed.