Data Source: NC Dept of Health and Human Services
COVID-19 Vaccines
There has been much discussion about COVID-19 vaccines; mandates, suggestions, rebellions. This graph tells a story we really aren't getting anywhere. It depicts the patterns of Percent Positivity Rate (PPR), Hospitalizations, and Vaccinations in NC. I am a dentist, and I
want to believe that scientists that are a lot smarter than I am are smart enough and honest enough to recognize what's going on and advise the most appropriate solutions, especially when it comes to the vaccines. (In full disclosure: I received two doses of Pfizer and had a shingles breakout hours after the second dose. I have not received a booster.)
There are two aims/claims of the COVID-19 vaccines; containment and mitigation.
"Vaccines Stop The Spread"
If you look at the Positivity Rate (red) and the Vaccination Rate (green), you'll see very little correlation. In fact the correlation factor between the two is 30 (out of 100). If the growing presence of the vaccine had the effect of stopping the spread, wouldn't we see the red line go downward and stay there?
NC isn't alone in seeing this phenomenon. On 8/5/21 CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky
went on CNN and said,
"Vaccines Prevent Severe Infection"
There is compelling documentation supporting vaccines' roles in keeping infected people from being severely infected, aka "out of the hospital". That is to say that on the graph, the growing green line will knock the blue line down, away from the red line.
When I look at what has happened, I see Hospitalizations (blue)
very closely following the pattern of PPR (red). Do any of you see disease severity fading with the growing presence of the vaccines? The only thing that I see affecting the behavior of the blue line (severity of sickness) is the introduction of the Omicron variant. If you look at ICU usage in NC, you see this exact same pattern.
Deaths
There has been much argument about the role COVID has played in recent deaths. Whatever the cause, we have undoubtedly seen a marked increase in deaths in the US since the advent of COVID-19.
It's important to note that in the six years preceding the outbreak, Deaths in the US very closely followed the population growth of adults over age 65. Once COVID-19 hit, we saw a 24% increase in deaths over the previous 6 years' average during each of the 2 years since. There are two points to make here:
Data Source: CDC
Deaths Due to COVID
If deaths followed the 2.5% growth rate seen with the 65+ population, we can estimate how many deaths we would have seen in 2020 and 2021 without the virus' presence. We can then deduce that the excess number of deaths is what is attributable to COVID. Those figures are 406K and 303K for each of the years, respectively. The media has reported anywhere from 800K-1M cumulative deaths, clearly an overstatement.
After seeing a 12% increase in deaths during the first year of the pandemic, the US voted for stark policy changes by electing a new president. After new policy implementations and increased understanding of virus containment and mitigation, what followed was a death rate that was still 9% higher than normal. Did the policy changes over the last year introduce a significantly different result with COVID-19's effect on humanity? It's difficult to conclude that they did.
Over the past two years America has invented vaccines, rolled them out to 2/3 of the population, implemented mask mandates, vaccine mandates, social distancing guidelines, non-essential business shutdowns, child vaccinations, government employment vaccine mandates, vaccine mandates for large-gathering attendance, and many more policies. Has any of it really made an impact? Based on these graphs' portrayal of the government's figures, I have a hard time concluding that we've had
any effect on the virus.