I have been saying for a while now, this kid really needs his conditioning to increase and still believe he needs 10lbs of muscle. I don't care how many stars he has, I am looking more at him as a potential player and think of how he may be able to help us next season. What I see is a small step back from Tony Bradley. Now I know, folks gonna freak at me saying that but before you do consider.
I love Tony's upside but Tony needs a bit more stamina to play for longer stretches and he needs to add some muscle. No matter how many stars Tony came in with, he is not a one & done type of kid, he isn't near ready for that next level, not yet. Right now Tony is a long kid that can make opposing players have to adjust their shot but gets physically moved around a bit. On the offensive end he scores right at the basket, does not show range yet. he is a kid that comes in and gives us 10-15mins of solid play but is not dominating, not right now, I do expect him to be more than this next season.
I see that in Manley, the ability to be a close in scorer, get some rebounds, alter some shots, maybe a bit less than Tony but not that far away. It does not matter to me 1 bit if the kid comes in as a 3star or a 5 star, he is still the same player no matter how one expert compared to another expert looks at him. It is way more about how he fits in with what we do and can he contribute and I think he can on a slightly lower par than Tony has as a freshman. But he could do even more, it is hard to tell until his stamina is improved and we see if he adds bulk in the weight room before the season.
Huffman I think is more physically ready, IMO he is more of a poor man's Bam, not much range as a shooter but a kid that can play strong and physically inside the paint with a solid motor. I think Huffman is a jump hook, step thru, mid range jumper away from being looked at as a 5 star. All moves he can develop with us, not the first time we have seen freshman big men with little range as freshmen. Tony, Ed Davis, Alec Stevson, JMM all come to mind in that aspect. I see him very similar to Alec with a touch better motor.