It was and is dumbbbbbbbbbbb to draft a defensive lineman at #1 (or 2 or 3) overall if you don't have a franchise QB on your roster.
Thought experiment:
- Yes, Garrett was hyped up to be a can't-miss, sure-thing DL. Totally agree with that assessment
- Let's assume for a moment that Garrett outperforms even his gaudy hype and goes on to be a future Hall of Fame DLman.
- Is HOFer Garrett going to make Cleveland a Super Bowl contender? Nope. Is it gonna do anything more than maybe add 1-2 wins per season? Nope.
- now, consider Cleveland instead drafts a QB who turns into a very solid (Top 8 in the league) QB.
- Is the play of said QB going to make Cleveland a Super Bowl contender? Quite possibly.
- Is the play of said QB going to make Cleveland a playoff team? Yes, almost assuredly.
This is a QB-driven league. If you don't have a good QB, you're going nowhere. Drafting a DLman #1 overall when the Browns have so many more pressing needs (i.e. QB) is dumb. Look at what the Rams did the past four seasons before this season. They probably had the best DL from top to bottom in the whole league. Did it do a damn thing for them? No, because their offense was bad.